In Season 2, Michael Dorman (Michael Dorman) plays a Wyoming game warden who discovers a hunter has been murdered in the mountains and realizes he is just one of a series of gruesome murders. To solve the case and catch the killer, Joe must deal with a radical anti-hunting activist, a pair of ghoul twins living outside, and his own tortured past. Joe and his wife Marybeth (Julianna Guill) discover that the murdered men are not as innocent as they seem. But when they dig too deep, they are forced to go on the run and fight for their lives.